rjdgull
TFF member
Admin
Posts: 12,227
|
Post by rjdgull on Dec 10, 2010 11:59:13 GMT
Of course, the traditional recourse for high treason was to be hung, drawn and quartered. I 'm sure I read somewhere that a knight of the realm had his sentence mitigated to just being hung for previous good service. Those were the days, but with the human rights act, even the death penalty for high treason has now gone out of the window in favour of spending time at her majesty's pleasure!
|
|
|
Post by aussie on Dec 10, 2010 12:22:43 GMT
at her majesty's pleasure! Surely she`s getting on a bit for that kind of thing!
|
|
|
Post by Bayern Gull on Dec 10, 2010 12:33:04 GMT
After watching the news I feel the students are well out of order and should have been dispersed with water cannons and rubber bullets . . .( Britain should be proud of the restraint shown by the police - long may it continue. It's infinitely preferable to what goes on in some countries where the police get completely out of control on such occasions (sometimes as result of actions by agent provocateurs).
|
|
chelstongull
TFF member
Posts: 6,759
Favourite Player: Jason Fowler
|
Post by chelstongull on Dec 10, 2010 12:56:34 GMT
Do you recon I`m being a bit soft then Steve? How about public floggings and a bit of tar and feathering? Chelston could bring his torches and noose, we could make a real knees up of it all! Yes you can be a big southern softie at times! . Latest suggestions far more in line with what is required and Chelston's involvement will definitely add a bit of je ne c'est quoi! Let's Party ;D I seriously think that Water Cannons should be used - possibly Rubber Bullets and Snatch (Ooh Matron) squads as back ups.
|
|
|
Post by stefano on Dec 10, 2010 14:09:05 GMT
Yes you can be a big southern softie at times! . Latest suggestions far more in line with what is required and Chelston's involvement will definitely add a bit of je ne c'est quoi! Let's Party ;D I seriously think that Water Cannons should be used - possibly Rubber Bullets and Snatch (Ooh Matron) squads as back ups. Best Smilie yet!! ;D
|
|
Dave
TFF member
Posts: 13,081
|
Post by Dave on Dec 10, 2010 20:34:36 GMT
While I can fully understand how the students feel, I was very saddened to see all the trouble that took place in London yesterday. I'm not one who would ever want to have any debt around my neck so I'm not sure if I was a young person now, I would choose to have further education.
But the facts are I suppose the country can't afford to provide free further education and so it has to be paid for somehow. If the figures I heard were correct, then having to pay £7.50 back per a month when you earn £21.000, does not sound that much and must surely be worth it for the education received by going to university.
I was reading on Wednesday that the London police were expecting trouble makers hell bend on causing trouble and attacking the police, to be joining in with the protests. I'm sure that happened and they were ones who caused a lot of the trouble, but I suspect some of the students were equally guilty.
In the past when I have watched TV coverage of protests etc, I have felt the police were in some way a part of the problems that might have happened, but I think they did a very hard job yesterday so very well.
Its sad to see some of the things that got damaged and attacked, its a disgrace what they did to the Royal car and you wonder if they felt such acts would help their fight.
The last time violence got a result was the Poll tax riots and you wonder if the mentality was it worked back then and this was the only way to win this time.
The one million peaceful protesters against the war sure never made any difference, but then getting ones way by using any violence should never be allowed to happen in our country.
It only went through on a very slender majority and my fear is it won't get the returns that are expected and I can see the £21.000 figure being lowered in years to come.
|
|
|
Post by aussie on Dec 11, 2010 9:08:36 GMT
So how did the Poll tax riots work exactly Dave? All the government did was changed it`s name to council tax, we still have to pay it, please explain! Or is it that easy to blag the people?
|
|
|
Post by the92ndfish on Dec 11, 2010 10:29:09 GMT
I wouldn't be so harsh upon the students for what happened mid week. The fact is that there is always a hardcore band of radical anarchists and socialists who target these demonstrations. They are quite active on my university campus spewing utter nonsense all the time and trying to recruit people to get involved with their campaigns against organised society. They hijack these events and use them as an excuse for their own agenda.
You don't see any of it in Devon but in London there is a strong far left presence amongst some groups of people. Besides the vast majority of students who protested a month ago weren't even at these events, they'd had their say and that was it.
I don't agree with the points of the protestors, didn't last month either but don't tar normal students with the same brush as these radical idiots. They're the same kind of people who burst in on the meetings between British Airways and their union causing havok and saying they were protecting the rights of the union when they were in fact harming the union and the union itself didn't even want them there. Also the same kind of people you see wandering around wearing Keffiyehs, praising the Palestinians and calling our own government murderers while supporting regimes such as Iran's. George Galloway is a good example.
As an aside I was more annoyed at them vandalising Churchill's statue than attacking the Royal's car. I couldn't give a stuff about Charles and Camilla, they're both awful people. The best thing the monarchy could do would be to skip Charles and go straight to William.
|
|
|
Post by aussie on Dec 11, 2010 10:36:39 GMT
When looking at the footage all you can see is trouble makers, where are these innocent students who are peaceful? Surely being students they should have some modicum of intellect, thus protesting in a neanderthal fasion is so not becoming of them, perhaps an equally intelligent form of protest would better reflect their position! Not having a go, just pointing out an observation!
|
|
|
Post by the92ndfish on Dec 11, 2010 10:46:56 GMT
When looking at the footage all you can see is trouble makers, where are these innocent students who are peaceful? Surely being students they should have some modicum of intellect, thus protesting in a neanderthal fasion is so not becoming of them, perhaps an equally intelligent form of protest would better reflect their position! Not having a go, just pointing out an observation! While all this was happening I was actually in a Political Theory class. My Professor is a crazy left winger who actually told my classmates to ditch class a couple weeks back and go to the protests. Anyways he was getting us to debate whether violence was right in protests and it was fairly obvious he considered that it was legitimate. The problem is exactly what you've just pinpointing. When a minority uses violence to protest it overshadows the point the majority are making. No one in a few years time is going to remember the student protests for being protests against raising tutition fees. They'll remember Millbank getting smashed up, the violence and fires in the midweek and the heir to the throne's car being smashed. The media focuses on these things and ignores the peaceful protestors. So saying where were they is kinda missing the point, they were there but they don't make a good sensationalist new story when people are setting fire to christmas trees, graffiting Winston and attacking the Prince's car.
|
|
|
Post by aussie on Dec 11, 2010 11:01:12 GMT
This is my point prescisely, if they could find a big impact method of making a point without looking stupid they would achieve far more and look a lot better for their efforts! Brains over brawn!
|
|
|
Post by lambethgull on Dec 11, 2010 12:26:48 GMT
So how did the Poll tax riots work exactly Dave? All the government did was changed it`s name to council tax, we still have to pay it, please explain! Or is it that easy to blag the people? Completely wrong. The Council Tax is a tax based on the old Rates system, which the Poll Tax ("Community Charge") replaced. Although Council Tax 'bands' are a blunt instrument and a poor way of assessing a person's ability to pay, they do at least recognise that a person's ability to pay should determine their contribution. The Poll Tax made no such allowance in principle, even if there were token efforts at reductions for the very poorest in practice.
|
|
|
Post by lambethgull on Dec 11, 2010 12:50:14 GMT
When looking at the footage all you can see is trouble makers, where are these innocent students who are peaceful? Surely being students they should have some modicum of intellect, thus protesting in a neanderthal fasion is so not becoming of them, perhaps an equally intelligent form of protest would better reflect their position! Not having a go, just pointing out an observation! Peaceful protesters don't make exciting headlines Aussie, which is why the one imbecile swinging from the cenotaph is in all the papers rather than the tens of thousands who did not. I was actually in Parliament Square on Thursday evening, and whilst there were people causing criminal damage, they were a minority. The montages on television make it look as if thousands of people were rioting for hours, but it wasn't like that. When you get thousands of people in a tightly packed area and passions are running high, some sort of conflict is almost inevitable. It's certainly true that these sorts of protests attract people looking for trouble, but police tactics playe into their hands to some degree. Kettling groups of protesters is effective and manageable when there are hundreds of protesters, but creates a dangerous and volatile situation when many thousands of people are involved. I agree with the point Baynern Gull made that we should be proud that police in his country do not use methods employed elsewhere. Those calling for the use of tear gas and rubber bullets should remember that it could be them on the end of those things if they happen to be in the wrong place at the wrong time.
|
|
|
Post by aussie on Dec 11, 2010 12:52:51 GMT
It boils down to the same f*cken thing mate, or do you not have to pay it? Tax is tax what ever you call it! They relabelled it, got away with it, and are laughing all the way to the bank! Blagged the lot of you didn`t they? Poll tax = council tax give or take a penny or two!
|
|
|
Post by lambethgull on Dec 11, 2010 13:01:05 GMT
I wouldn't be so harsh upon the students for what happened mid week. The fact is that there is always a hardcore band of radical anarchists and socialists who target these demonstrations. They are quite active on my university campus spewing utter nonsense all the time and trying to recruit people to get involved with their campaigns against organised society. They hijack these events and use them as an excuse for their own agenda. You don't see any of it in Devon but in London there is a strong far left presence amongst some groups of people. Besides the vast majority of students who protested a month ago weren't even at these events, they'd had their say and that was it. I don't agree with the points of the protestors, didn't last month either but don't tar normal students with the same brush as these radical idiots. They're the same kind of people who burst in on the meetings between British Airways and their union causing havok and saying they were protecting the rights of the union when they were in fact harming the union and the union itself didn't even want them there. Also the same kind of people you see wandering around wearing Keffiyehs, praising the Palestinians and calling our own government murderers while supporting regimes such as Iran's. George Galloway is a good example. As an aside I was more annoyed at them vandalising Churchill's statue than attacking the Royal's car. I couldn't give a stuff about Charles and Camilla, they're both awful people. The best thing the monarchy could do would be to skip Charles and go straight to William. It was a bit of paint on the plinth of the statue for God's sake - it'll have been cleaned off before the weekend's over. I was more annoyed at the pointless attack on the Royals' car. I'm not a supporter of the monarchy (and this thing about missing Charles to go to William simply serves to highlight the absurdity of monarchy). Attacks on property are one thing, attacks on middle-aged people sitting in cars (even if they are as silly as Prince Charles) is totally unacceptable.
|
|