keyberrygull
TFF member
Posts: 994
Favourite Player: Steve Cooper
|
Post by keyberrygull on Jul 1, 2010 20:00:53 GMT
Defeat at the hands of the Germans last Sunday seems a distant memory that will soon be forgotten by many but just who caused England's early exit. The manager, the players, bad luck or the Premiership? No doubt all four of the above influenced the performance but as long as they can keep blaming each other, not one of them will be singled out and nothing will change.
Bad luck?
The manager can only pick from a limited number of players playing in the top flight of English football.
Exhausted players (except Tevez and a few more) are spent and can only give so much over a 12 month period.
The Premiership can boast the worlds top footballers and lay claim to being the best league in the world.
NO CHANGE = NO CHANCE
|
|
davethegull
TFF member
Posts: 1,094
Favourite Player: Dave Caldwell
|
Post by davethegull on Jul 2, 2010 8:36:33 GMT
I've refrained from commenting on our national team until i calmed down. Who's to blame? The spineles c#&ts who pulled on the shirt, that's who! Tired?? Don't make me laugh! I watched the game in Bangkok and the thais all said that england were lazy, and that about sums it up. Most of these show ponies don't know hard graft and never will. The only excercise these intellectual midgets ever really get is picking up their paychecks. There celebrity lifestyle removes them from the fans and it's just business to them and promoting their brand. They find themselves a trophy bimbo who is equally vapid and then believe all sychophants telling them how great they are and giving them egos way above their lowlife level. You only have to look at the behaviour of Terry, Cole, Lampard and the soon to be ungagged story on Gerrard as well as a host of others to form the conclusion that these people don't live in the real world. They think they can do what they like, pick up the money and go thro the motions. Not one true professional among them. These people are scum, always have been always will be. Thay would be in gaol if they weren't footballers. Trailertrash with money and no brains. So to answer the question, it's the players! Anyway, here's a few jokes to cheer us up! Does Capello remind you of someone? ? Whats the difference between Cinderella and the England football team? Cinderella wanted to get to the ball.... Osama bin Laden has just released a new TV message to prove he is still alive. He said that the England Team performance on Saturday was completely s**t. British intelligence have dismissed the claim, stating that the message could have been recorded anytime in the last 44 years. Robert Green - The only man to leave Africa with out catching anything . In a statement from broadcasting house, all future England games will now be shown on the gay porn channel. It is thought that 11 arsåholes being regularly shafted is too explicit for regular TV. I can't believe we only managed a draw against a s**t team we should easily have beaten......I'm ashamed to call myself Algerian. The England team went to visit an orphanage in South Africa this morning, "its so good to put a smile on the faces of people with no hope, constantly struggling, and facing the impossible" said Jamal Omboto, aged 6. Fifa have released a statement saying the fan didn't break into the dressing room after all, but was let in by Rob Green. What's the difference between Rob Green's spill and BP's spill? - Robert Green has got a cap for his. Fabio Capello was wheeling his shopping trolley across the supermarket car park when he noticed an old lady struggling with her bags of shopping. He stopped and asked, "Can you manage dear?" To which the old lady replied, "No way. You got yourself into this f*****g mess, don't ask me to sort it out..." The FA have launched an inquiry to find out how a fan found his way into the dressing room. And another enquiry into how Aaron Lennon found his way into the dressing room. .
|
|
|
Post by lambethgull on Jul 2, 2010 13:34:37 GMT
It's easy to blame 'the Premiership,' but I blame those who provide a market for the Premiership - which includes subscribers to subscription TV channels, purchasers of tabloid newspapers and purchasers of vastly ovepriced tickets and merchandise. Without a market to support it, the Premiership would not be the beast it is.
To hear morons in the pub or at work bemoaning the failure of England one day and then talking about 'their' Premiership side's latest foreign signing the next is enough to turn a man to violence.
|
|
Rob
TFF member
Posts: 3,607
Favourite Player: Asa Hall
|
Post by Rob on Jul 3, 2010 21:56:47 GMT
John Terry
|
|
|
Post by frankfurt gull on Jul 4, 2010 12:52:55 GMT
the German Bundesliga is just as rigorous as the Premier League, the German players play just as many games in a season and there are also lots of foreign players playing in the Bundesliga. So just why do they do so much better than us every time? The Germans take their sport very seriously and football, right down to Sunday League level is extremely well organized. Even small village teams of South Devon League Division 7 level have a trainer who gets paid 400 - 500 Euros a month. Training at least twice a week. Promising youngster are noted early and their skills developed. The standard of sport facilities is also very high. When I think of the Council football pitches in Torquay I can only shake my head. They would put cows out to grass on them over here. So my opinion is that the Germans have put more effort into it at grass roots level, the basis is therefore stronger and they reep the rewards. To answer keyberrys question, to blame is the FA in my opinion.
|
|
|
Post by chrish on Jul 4, 2010 14:21:31 GMT
the German Bundesliga is just as rigorous as the Premier League, the German players play just as many games in a season and there are also lots of foreign players playing in the Bundesliga. So just why do they do so much better than us every time? The Germans take their sport very seriously and football, right down to Sunday League level is extremely well organized. Even small village teams of South Devon League Division 7 level have a trainer who gets paid 400 - 500 Euros a month. Training at least twice a week. Promising youngster are noted early and their skills developed. The standard of sport facilities is also very high. When I think of the Council football pitches in Torquay I can only shake my head. They would put cows out to grass on them over here. So my opinion is that the Germans have put more effort into it at grass roots level, the basis is therefore stronger and they reep the rewards. The big difference is that young German players get experience younger. Marko Marin who's now 21 and in the World Cup squad has already had 3 seasons under his belt at Borussia Moenchengladbach and Borussia Moenchengladbach II in three different divisions before he was transferred to Werder Bremen where he's played in over 30 games this season. He might get Thomas Mueller's starting place for the semi final. He's two footed, quick and skillful. I think that the reserve teams playing in competitive leagues help the development of German players a lot. Thomas Mueller now 20 years old has been at Bayern Munich since he was 10! German academies seem to work. At the moment, who in the UK is actually producing young English players good enough to warrant a starting place in a Premier League? I hope that the likes of Danny Welbeck, Ryan Shawcross, Adam Johnson (ssshhh he's got a left foot!) Kieron Gibbs, Jack Wilshire, Joe Hart, Jack Rodwell and Dan Gosling develop as we hope they do. I also hope that Fabio opts for youth now and dumps the likes of Terry, Gerrard, Lampard, Defoe, Heskey, Carragher (tell me again why he was in the World Cup 23, I'm still confused), Upson (dear god). I think players like Milner, Dawson, Huddlestone and Ashley Young should be included. I have my doubts about Ashley Young. At 24 years of age with his ability he should have more than 7 caps and he's one of the ones who's had first team experience from the start. The problem is the Premiership as far as I'm concerned. The rewards are so huge and the amount of money circulating is so unbelievable that there's hardly any motivation to have the time and the patience to develop young English kids. I'm hoping that Steve McClaren might try to attract some younger English players to Wolfsburg in the future. Not many British let alone English players have played top flight football in Germany. The only ones that spring to mind are Kevin Keegan at HSV, Tony Woodcock at Cologne, Paul Lambert at Borussia Dortmund, Mark Hughes and Alan McNally at Bayern Munich. We've had no English players in the French League since Hoddle, Hately and Waddle. None in Serie A since Jay Bothroyd's two year spell at Perugia and Lee Sharpe's 3 game loan spell at Sampdoria when David Platt was in charge. All we have abroad now are Matt Derbyshire who plays for Olympiacos Piraeus in Greece and Darius Vassell played last season for Ankaragücü in Turkey and hopes to stay in Turkey providing he finds a new club. Jermaine Pennant is the only English player in La Liga at Real Zaragoza. There's a story of a wasted talent either through a lack of proper development or more importantly in Pennant's case a lack of discipline and professionalism. Or maybe it's a case that our young players are so pampered in England on big contracts in the reserves that they've little motivation to move abroad and challenge themselves. Maybe Roy Keane is right and it's because that most of them are too lazy to take football seriously enough as they're happy with the Cadillac Escalade and a never ending conveyor belt of tarts they can spit roast with the help of a team mate or two. Or maybe it's because they aren't good enough in the first place. I think that Merse posted a comment a while back saying that Capello had less English players who played top flight football to choose from than any other previous England manager. I think the percentage of English players in the premier league was in the low 30s from memory. Obviously this needs to be higher. You actually wonder just how many of the 30-odd% are actually of international calibre? A lot less than 30% thats for sure. It think it's a wise move to keep Capello for the last two years of this contract. If he can install some sense into the younger generation and help develop a new generation then he's worth the money the FA pay him. I still think he's doing a better job than Sven and unlike dear Svennis he's hasn't had the luxury of having certain players fit and available and young enough to run around for 90 minutes. I'll concede that Sven had a good Euro 2004 tournament but that squad is a lot better than the one Capello had, Ian Walker excepted! EDIT: I completely forgot about Owen Hargreaves being English and playing in Germany. But he moved from Calgary to Munich when he was 16 and then was developed by Bayern Munich. He was also the second footballer in history to play for England without having played in an English League. Who can name the other?
|
|
|
Post by frankfurt gull on Jul 4, 2010 15:40:06 GMT
I think that the reserve teams playing in competitive leagues help the development of German players a lot. Thomas Mueller now 20 years old has been at Bayern Munich since he was 10! German academies seem to work. you have picked up a very good point there chris, the reserve teams of major clubs play in the German third division. this only happens with the loanee system in england. imagine having liverpool reserves in league two. one of the best games i remember seeing was frankfurt under 18s playing on a pitch outside the stadium before a bundesliga match. the game against bochum was crap in comparison an hour later.
|
|
merse
TFF member
Posts: 2,684
|
Post by merse on Jul 4, 2010 17:35:58 GMT
He was also the second footballer in history to play for England without having played in an English League. Who can name the other? That was Hibernian striker Joe Baker who subsequently joined Arsenal.
|
|
merse
TFF member
Posts: 2,684
|
Post by merse on Jul 4, 2010 18:13:44 GMT
you have picked up a very good point there chris, the reserve teams of major clubs play in the German third division. this only happens with the loanee system in england. imagine having liverpool reserves in league two. No thankyou! You also have to take into account though that German football ends any realistic comparison with the English game at the level immediately below the Bundesliga, with Bundesliga 2 being the only other fully national league. The third tier is split into regional leagues so that two relegations will see a side going from the equivelant of the Premiership to the geographical likeness of Conference South....................although the standard of footbal is much higher than that. It is in these leagues that reserve teams of the bigger clubs play, and reserve sides of Liga 2 and regional clubs merely slot in further down the pyramid, so that a level four club like Chemnitz can find themselves facing the reserves of neighbouring Liga 2 Dynamo Dresden.....................not a very inspiring fixture list for a club the equivelant of Torquay United and not one I would like to see adopted here. How would YOU like The Gulls to be in the same league as Argyle Reserves?
|
|
|
Post by chrish on Jul 4, 2010 18:18:05 GMT
He was also the second footballer in history to play for England without having played in an English League. Who can name the other? That was Hibernian striker Joe Baker who subsequently joined Arsenal. Via Torino where he played up front with Denis Law and he was almost killed in a car crash after he drove around a roundabout the wrong way.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 4, 2010 18:39:55 GMT
That was Hibernian striker Joe Baker who subsequently joined Arsenal. Did Joe Baker have a Scottish accent given he spent most of his childhood there? Indeed, he died in the Motherwell area close to where he grew up. Liverpool-born, English father/Scottish mother and a brother - Gerry - who was born in New York and won caps for the USA.
|
|
|
Post by chrish on Jul 4, 2010 19:25:42 GMT
you have picked up a very good point there chris, the reserve teams of major clubs play in the German third division. this only happens with the loanee system in england. imagine having liverpool reserves in league two. No thankyou! You also have to take into account though that German football ends any realistic comparison with the English game at the level immediately below the Bundesliga, with Bundesliga 2 being the only other fully national league. The third tier is split into regional leagues so that two relegations will see a side going from the equivelant of the Premiership to the geographical likeness of Conference South....................although the standard of footbal is much higher than that. It is in these leagues that reserve teams of the bigger clubs play, and reserve sides of Liga 2 and regional clubs merely slot in further down the pyramid, so that a level four club like Chemnitz can find themselves facing the reserves of neighbouring Liga 2 Dynamo Dresden.....................not a very inspiring fixture list for a club the equivelant of Torquay United and not one I would like to see adopted here. How would YOU like The Gulls to be in the same league as Argyle Reserves? There's actually 3 national divisions now. You have the Bundesliga and the 2. Bundesliga. In 2008 the 3.Liga was founded. There are 3 regional divisions (Regionalliga) that feed into it. The Champion of each Regionalliga then gets promoted the 3. Liga. Underneath that there are then 12 Regional Oberliga divisions feeding into the Regionalliga. At moment there are three Bundesliga sides (Werder Bremen, Bayern Munich and VFB Stuttgart) who run reserve teams in the 3. Liga. As fate would have it these 3 Bundesliga teams currently provide 14 out of the 23 players in Germany's World Cup squad. In the Regionalliga divisions you have all the reserve teams from all the other big Bundesliga teams. As for Karl-Marx Stadt. It's not Dynamo Dresden reserves fault that they've sunk so low. They should've never released Carl Priso.
|
|
merse
TFF member
Posts: 2,684
|
Post by merse on Jul 4, 2010 20:48:07 GMT
Morike Sako has been a huge hit playing as a striker for St Pauli and has now been involved in two promotions as they have returned to the Bundesliga 1, but I wonder if they consider him good enough to play at that exalted level? Apparently not, he only got three starts and four appearances fom the bench in Liga 2 last season and not surprisinlgy got released as the club prepares for life at the highest level. A massive culture change playing at the very top level just as in this country and the fans are being asked to stump up nearly a £100 for replica kits just to give you some idea of the reality of following a club in thosae exalted levels as opposed to one at the third level of national football. By the start of the season The Millerntor will have completed a wholesale redevelopment in a little under three years so that it now boasts four all seater (with the usual ubiquitous German option of certain areas being usable as standing zones by flipping the seat backs onto the seats) stands with extensive sorporate and recreational facilities inbuilt..................a far cry from the rickety old ground of recent times.
|
|
|
Post by chrish on Jul 4, 2010 22:29:47 GMT
There's actually 3 national divisions now. You have the Bundesliga and the 2. Bundesliga. In 2008 the 3.Liga was founded. There are 3 regional divisions (Regionalliga) that feed into it. The Champion of each Regionalliga then gets promoted the 3. Liga. Underneath that there are then 12 Regional Oberliga divisions feeding into the Regionalliga.
As for Karl-Marx Stadt. It's not Dynamo Dresden reserves fault that they've sunk so low. They should've never released Carl Priso. I stand corrected...............my expanding family and diminishing disposable income has done for my trips to Germany in recent years. What is your opinion of the inlusion of reserve teams so high up the German pyramid Chris? I know it's accepted in plenty of countries, but it is the most un British aspect of continental football I can think of. I think the point Frankfurtgull made about the vary basic facilities a German community would provide for it's football club say a lot for the German, and indeed Belgian, French and Dutch way of doing things; actually every other European country I've visited compared to England for that matter; and that I think is the crux of the very different way our football is going in direct contrast to other countries which ALL appear to be upwardly mobile and progessing whilst we regress. But then, in other countries you don't get playing fields being sold off by politicians, nor urban transit systems severely underfunded and all but vandalised by politicians ~ particularly Conservative politicians ~ it's all a question of recognising the value of the quality of life as against having the mentality that everything needs to be profitable and exploitable. I remember thirty years ago refereeing a game in a small German town called Bad Pyrmont as a guest referee in a regional league and arriving at the stadium to find under soil pop up sprinklers doing their stuff before the evening kick off and recall thinking at the time that this town was roughly of the same population as Newton Abbot and comparing these facilities with the cheap jack Rec in NA. Funny place BP, rather like a German version of Buxton ~ full of old folk taking the waters of a spa town high in the wooded hills and surrounded by baroque architecture. They have a weird local bye law in Bad Pyrmont that forbids the use of any motor vehicle in the town centre after 10pm and I was told that many a law abiding German has pushed his Merc to the edge of the designated "Verbattenzone" What a contrast to Chemnitz (formerly Karl Marx Stadt) and yes TB1 and I both surmised how Karl Priso's heart must have dropped, if not his jaw; when he arrived in that run down, miserable dump having signed for the local club. I bet he was soon on the phone to his agent when he surveyed the desolated old place. Fancy committing yourself to a couple of years there, and I bet they are one of those clubs who made sure any prospective new signings were taken to a neighbouring town or city to do the negotiations...................not a problem that Torquay United ever face apart from maybe that interminable crawl along the main road from the Penn Inn Roundabout to Plainmoor! Well, as Frankfurt Gull said, the Germans take their football very seriously indeed and it's reflected on how their clubs are set up. Most of the big clubs are also Sport's Clubs offering many different sports not just football. St Pauli actually run a Rugby team as well believe it or not. I paid a visit a couple of years ago to the lovely Wildparkstadion in Karlsruhe and I was struck by how organised the coaching set up was. There were kids from many different age ranges having very specific training in small groups being supervised by a couple of coaches. The guy who I spoke to said that the club really needed to develop young players in order to keep them financially sound. I think this sums up German football in general. For the most part clubs seem to have more of a realistic view that they need to aspire to a level of football which is more sustainable. There's none of this investing millions on a complete Pipedream. All the money spent at Portsmouth and they're still at Fratton Park and facing a huge mountain of debt to pay back. I can't imagine this kind of thing going on in Germany. It says a lot for football that this year's Champions League Final between Internazionale and FC Bayern was overshadowed (in this country) by the £90 million play off final between Blackpool and Cardiff. If clubs like Blackpool, West Brom and Burnley are sensible they should take the £60 million in the Premier League and the £30 million in parachute payments and just yo-yo up and down until they find themselves in a strong financial position, which shouldn't on the face of it take too long! As for introducing Premier League reserve teams into the league. Well I think it might bring some benefits in the development of young players. Instead of keeping young players in non competitive games they would be thrown into matches in competitve leagues. It can't be bad for them can it? As long as the club's can't go any higher than League 1. If there needs to be a bridge between League 1 and the Premiership then players can be loaned to Championship sides. I think the biggest potential impact of including say 10 reserve sides of the biggest 10 Premiership clubs would be that it might impact the current loan system because potentially the likes of say "Tottenham Hotspur A" joining our league might not facilitate loanees like Adam Smith or Jamie Cox and the trio that Yeovil had last season. But this could be negated by Championship clubs looking to loan their players out as per normal. Another is the possible low away followings that you might get initially. But you might also find that these sides might find themselves getting support from fans getting increasingly disillusioned with Premiership football but wishing to continue a link of sorts with the club. I think it would need a radical shake up within the game and a change in our mentality both in how we deal with the tradition and how realistic we need our clubs to be. What's more important? Building solid setups which produce results or just doing the typical British thing of chucking vast sums of money without actually addressing the issue? At moment I can't see how lower league football can be sustainable for some clubs who like Accrington "survive" on an average of 1400 home gates. But would the inclusion of playing Man Utd A, Liverpool A, Chelsea A, Aston Villa A, Man City A, Everton A, Arsenal A, Newcastle A, Tottenham A and West Ham A de-value lower league football? At the moment this model doesn't appear to be harming Germany and Spain's development of younger players. I don't believe the Italians have the same set up as Germany and Spain. If you take Barcelona B for example, not only have they developed the likes of Lionel Messi, Xavi, Andres Iniesta, Victor Valdes and Carles Puyol but they've also had the added bonus of blooding new coaches. Current Barca manager Josep Guardiola spent two seasons as head coach of Barcelona B, as did a certain Juande Ramos back in 1996-1997. Luis Enrique is their current coach. What's the betting that he'll be Josep Guardiola's succesor? Real Madrid run a similar setup and their team has helped produce the likes of Raul, Guti, Ilker Casillas, Rafael Martin Vasquez, Michel, Emilio "The Vulture" Butragueno and a certain Mr Rafael Benitez before he formed The Mavericks and started reading out rants towards Fergie written down on Tesco Extra receipts.
|
|
|
Post by lambethgull on Jul 4, 2010 23:29:10 GMT
I know it's accepted in plenty of countries, but it is the most un British aspect of continental football I can think of. The day watching Torquay means seeing us provide training opposition and facilities for the also-rans of Premiership teams is the day I’ll hang up my scarf. I’d sooner watch us play Accrington 46 times a season than see us suffer the indignity of hosting Liverpool Reserves in a League fixture.
|
|