Dave
TFF member
Posts: 13,081
|
Post by Dave on Jan 14, 2009 23:35:00 GMT
I think you are spot on Chris and as you say some swearing by some, can be funny, sadly that is not what is happening now on the popside. The stewards are a lot better these days, many our now local people who have been trained up and we do not have so many Plymouth ones.
I think it firstly needs to come from the club and like everything in life, taking some action(IE remove one or two from the ground) will have a very quick effect in dealing with and stopping the problem. If only some early action had been taken at the famous Wanderers match, it might not have got out of control like it did.
|
|
|
Post by Budleigh on Jan 15, 2009 9:00:49 GMT
When I was at school if a boy in class started to try it on with bad behaviour they were removed from the class, given a talking too, generally in a civilised way that tried to get across what they were doing wrong, and asked to wait out in the corridor until they had calmed down. Often this ended in humiliation for the offender and worked. How about this tactic at the game? Nobody wants to see these young lads kicked out of the ground or even banned as in a lot of cases they don't even realise what they are doing is offensive or incorrect. So when the unacceptable chanting starts a couple of stewards should take any known ring leader down the stairs, or to the end of the pop side, and have a word and explain the situation, then after a bit of cooling off take him back (it's nearly always a he...) and watch the situation... Keep doing this until all the culprits have been given the same treatment... Then if one does it a second time... That's the time to kick him out for the game... Hopefully a lesson will be learnt and the offenders will know they're skating on thin ice... Of course they could always be sent to the headmasters study, sorry... Colin Lee's office, for a ticking off!!
|
|
|
Post by buster on Jan 15, 2009 13:19:18 GMT
I can understand that the use of particular words whether they be swear words or not may be offensive to some.
As a school kid I quite happily shouted and swore at the ref, the police and the opposition from the hallowed steps of the mini stand without any thought to who may be offended. I`ve now grown up, a little, and now am a little more choosy in the words I use dependant on the company. If though I find myself in a situation where I don`t feel comfortable I don`t go. My son and I always sit in the family stand and to be honest on the occasions I`ve been to Plainmoor the atmosphere has been such that you can`t pick out too many words from the pop side.
I agree with forever, the ground could more easily be sectioned off to attract particular elements of our fans. I personally think the vocal home fans should be at the marnham end. The away fans should be located in the pop, with a section nearest to the family stand for the young gulls.
I find people who make such comments that they will not go again or prefer to watch Argyle now. Are only seeking to make excuses and are at best floating spectators. Surely you go to a game as a die hard fan of that club, or you go with the knowledge that on occasion you may see or hear something that you wouldn`t in your own home. If the ground was sectioned and the fans knew in advance they could choose the location of their seat/step accordingly. As a young teenager I don`t think I would have taken too kindly to someone telling me to mind my words.
buster
|
|
Dave
TFF member
Posts: 13,081
|
Post by Dave on Jan 15, 2009 17:32:26 GMT
BudleighGull, I think your idea is a very good one and I would hope that could be tried before any fan ever got banned. No one wants see see fans removed from the ground and should only be done if talking to the ring leaders failed to get the required result.
While I agree that the family stand should always be a no swearing stand, I really don't agree that the c word should be used anywhere else, as I said I do not have a problem with most of what gets sung, its only really this latest one I strongly object too.
Any fan who pays to enter the ground should be free to stand where they want, you can't have a small group being allowed to use this word and therefore dictating where all the other fans must stand if they don't like it. Lets take the most sensible route here and that is for the stewards to start playing their part, by trying to talk to the offenders.
If that fails then sorry, if a few need to be ejected for the sake of getting the message across, then so be it. I do not want to spoil anyones fun or enjoyment at the game, but the fact is, it is being spoiled for many of us, by having to hear the c word being song.
|
|
|
Post by forevertufc on Jan 15, 2009 19:49:06 GMT
hi dave ,i do know of the group your talking about ,and whist they would not cause trouble now ,in a few years time they will be no longer wet behind the ears ,may have grown up by then or they will go the other way .
all iam saying is as a parent you have to make an informed choice,if you take your child onto the popside you must expect to see ,hear things are not appropriate for children.
i do try not to be two faced ,like buster i to stood in the mini stand as a teenager ,and yes i used the f ,w and ashamed to say the c word as well ,i turn 40 in 2 weeks and am now grown up look back and do clearly see the error of my ways.
can you stop swearing no its to late ,walk through any town or city when the schools have finished for the day ,and you will see/hear children running all over the place,calling each other f/ing w and f/ing c , i think do gooding society is to blame ,as a child if i swore my mum would have put soap in my mouth ,do that now to a child and you would be charged with assaulting a minor .
i go on the popside with my 11 year old son ,because as a parent i don't believe in sheltering children from the harsh reality of life, some parent's think they should shelter their children ,neither opinion in my view is wrong.
its not right however swearing seems to be the excepted norm ,and what iam trying to say is if don't want to hear it don't go on the popside the family/grandstand is the place to go.
and long term if the only problem we have is some plastic wannabe kids swearing then we have not done to bad. compared with a club like aldershot who now have a huge police bill to pay because of a group of hooligans who have attached themselves to their club.
|
|
Dave
TFF member
Posts: 13,081
|
Post by Dave on Jan 15, 2009 20:06:09 GMT
forevertufc, I think as young lads they are probably all fine and as you say not the sort to cause problems and that is something to be thankful for.
I think your approach to bringing up your children is fine and I would agree its better for kids not to be over protected or have the real world hid from them. My point really is that this one word is just not suitable at any football match, I have stood on the Popside for over 40 years and don't see why I should have to go to the family stand, just because a small group now think its OK to use the C word in a song.
As I said lets try and get them to see the errors of their ways, you never know, but them knowing it upsets other fans may be enough for them to want to stop.
|
|
|
Post by ohtobeatplainmoor on Jan 15, 2009 20:16:48 GMT
I've got a feeling that this might be the small group that were at Forest Green in the Setanta Shield the other week that I mentioned in my match updates. A bunch of absolute idiots and their witless drivel that they come-out with is simply embarassing to be associated with.
|
|
|
Post by buster on Jan 15, 2009 20:36:36 GMT
Not wanting to rock the boat but are these the ramblings of old men? Have you forgotten what it was like for a young teenager to watch a game? I`m with forever on this one. You have to accept that for better or for worse Britain ain`t the place it was 30 years ago. I`m not saying it is behaviour that i support or condone now, far from it, as said previously we stear clear of such characters. But as a teenager I looked forward to being in the mini stand and the half time walk to/from the babbacombe end. I`ve not grown up a thug or a disrespectful adult. So maybe we need to get things into perspective a little. Don`t try to change the ways of others, the problem may be you not being able to tolerate their actions. The club could put out a message to politely ask supporters to refrain from swearing, but if you are wanting stewards to intervene you are risking aggravation of the situation. The privilege of watching the Gulls is not determined by the length of following them.
buster
|
|
midlandstufc
TFF member
Posts: 945
Favourite Player: Dawkins lol
|
Post by midlandstufc on Jan 15, 2009 20:36:38 GMT
Mind you, it's not just the kids nowadays. I remember the Coventry FA Cup match of 20 years ago and idiots trying to wind up the Coventry fans through the segregation fence. You know the type 'come on and have a go if your hard enough!', whilst being behind other TUFC fans, a seven foot steel fence and a load of stewards. Oh how I laughed/was embarassed as the coppers frog-marched them out with thumbs bent up their backs. The sheer cost of the day (was a student {sorry} back then) made me behave myself let alone anything else!
4eva - good post mate.
|
|
Dave
TFF member
Posts: 13,081
|
Post by Dave on Jan 15, 2009 20:48:56 GMT
Buster I do not consider myself old I still feel a boy and while I listen to Terry Wogan on BBC2 I'm certainly not a TOG. So I can't agree with that view point, you say The privilege of watching the Gulls is not determined by the length of following them. I fully agree, but my point really was in all those years we never had songs with the C word in it, so why should we now. No Britain is not the place now I remember 30 years ago, but that is no reason why we should except what is going on now, at least 30 years ago we had respect and behaved far better. No one is asking for heavy handed stewards to start throwing out the offenders, but surly its better to nip this in the bud, rid the ground of the C word, before it just becomes acceptable and we end up looking a not so nice club and ground to visit.
|
|
|
Post by mickyflash on Jan 15, 2009 21:28:53 GMT
well, heres my two pennies worth on this...
I know of the group of lads who sing this song, and while I don't stand directly next to them I am within earshot of the chants/ stupid (literally) and as onthebeat says pure witless remarks made by the group.
The Thing is, the society we live in today (did I really just say that? crikey I'm getting old!) they, unfortunately really don't see any difference between the C word and the F word! its funny when they say it in the playground and its funny when they sing it n the popside
I am a little younger than some of you on here (sorry ;D) so maybe I can look past the swearing easier than others, as it has always been a part of my football life. yes I remember the C word in question being used by people much older than myself when i first started going to the plainmoor at the tender age 13!
I do swear at the game, at the ref, at the opposition, at the away fans, and at that cheating b*****d that dived for the penalty. I do not join in with that chant because of my own principles.
My point is though this whole topic is based on opinion. Many on here are offended or do not want to hear that word while watching a game of football, but we cant seriously expect stewards to take action against one word that some find offensive and not others. my language may offend people when I'm at the game! Many will not want to hear the F word, and then some don't want to here the B word, where do you draw the line? As a club, officially, we need to either eradicate it all or let it slide. and I feel Football at our level has gone too far down the road to eradicate it all.
I was watching Everton v Man Utd at Goodison earlier this season and the language used their by the evertonians you would not believe, it would make our very own clan of idiots blush, I watched this one old lady spend the best part of a minute to stand up only to hurl an alphabet of swearwords at Christiano Ronaldo, now that really was an atmosphere even I did not feel comfortable in and it did feel good to be back on the pop side!
I do not think the stewards interfering more than they do is the answer, they have a hard enough job with that particular group as it is, everytime any of them come within ear shot of that area a we hate Argyle chant develops. the kids are pushing boundaries with the stewards and seeing how far they can go, little chats with the ring leaders will just make them worse. the bottom line is they don't respect them, and until one/all them gets ejected from the ground (which I don't particularly want to see) I don't think they will.
I will say this however, It is easy to disregarded this group as trouble makers, and while they are by no means my favorite people at plainmoor, I do feel for them sometimes. They are young and dare I say they don't know any different. I can physically see on their faces looking for the approval of others on the pop, and the trouble is that there are a few 'special adults' (thats the nice way of saying retarded) that have taken the group in and are feeding their behavior.
If my language at a game was offending anybody I would like to know about it and if it offends you i suggest you tell them that yourself, not via the forum but face to face. while as a group they may laugh at you personally when enough people tell them this every time they sing the song they will soon get the message
The popside used to be full of wit. the best comedy in the world was found on the terraces of a football game not the mindless drivel that these kids are coming out with! but nobody is saying anything and they don't see it as wrong or unfunny. If I had said half the dumb-witted remarks that these kids are saying when I first stared watching Torquay I would of been slaughtered by the old pros of the popside. I remember one of my very first games at Torquay wearing my brand new Man Utd shirt! how pleased I was walking up to the game watching a proper Football match in proper Football shirt. I got slaughtered for the whole 90 mins but you know what, I never did it again!
|
|
Dave
TFF member
Posts: 13,081
|
Post by Dave on Jan 15, 2009 21:36:51 GMT
A very good post micky and some excellent points made, I 'm going to read it a few more times and give some thought to your main points, you never know you may have converted me ;D
|
|
|
Post by stuartB on Jan 15, 2009 22:00:58 GMT
A very good post micky and some excellent points made, I 'm going to read it a few more times and give some thought to your main points, you never know you may have converted me ;D foff, c u next tuesday!! you converted? ;D well done Mickey
|
|
Dave
TFF member
Posts: 13,081
|
Post by Dave on Jan 15, 2009 22:06:56 GMT
A very good post micky and some excellent points made, I 'm going to read it a few more times and give some thought to your main points, you never know you may have converted me ;D foff, c u next tuesday!! you converted? ;D well done Mickey You won't be getting a vote for that post Stuartb ;D
|
|
|
Post by stuartB on Jan 15, 2009 22:11:07 GMT
foff, c u next tuesday!! you converted? ;D well done Mickey You won't be getting a vote for that post Stuartb ;D maybe not from you
|
|