merse
TFF member
Posts: 2,684
|
Post by merse on Oct 23, 2008 3:14:44 GMT
The English football pyramid is a wonderful thing that makes our football unique in the world. Look at the Non League Paper and, thanks to James Wright's efforts (usually after he's been to a game most evenings), you'll see the results of hundreds of games played under lights up and down the country. In which other country does this happen on such a sustained level? A very good post Bartondowns, but with respect; the English Pyramid system was modelled on those in other European countries.............in particular Italy, Germany and France and only requires so much midweek football because we have a "culture" of it. In other countries they don't and thus create divisions with less teams and devote midweek time for coaching and training. Another underlying reason for the superior technique often on view when compared to English football. After All, if you're playing Saturday/Tuesday/Saturday;what time is there for working on your weaknesses?
|
|
Dave
TFF member
Posts: 13,081
|
Post by Dave on Oct 23, 2008 5:31:50 GMT
bartondowns, the thanks should really be from me, I read back a thread like this and Its people like you who have written such excellent posts, that make the forum.
Yes I got It to look like It does and work to keep It all running, but all my efforts would be wasted If the forum did not get the first class posts, that the forum Is getting known for.
So a thank you, too all our members, firstly for joining and showing that I was correct, that this forum was needed and secondly for the part you all play as a writer or a reader Of the forum.
Without such excellent members there would be no Torquay Fans Forum Many thanks Dave
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 23, 2008 8:38:26 GMT
Spot on, Merse, about other European models. You can go further and argue that the English pyramid is neither complete nor entirely logical (especially from non-league level 5 downwards). Heaven forbid, we may even have to acknowledge that English Rugby Union has a purer, more workable system.
It might have been more correct for me to say the "culture" surrounding English non-league football is what makes it special/different/unique. Midweek football (right or wrong), paid players, paying spectators, media coverage, programmes, refreshments, sponsorship, clubhouses, etc - all of these can be found down right down to very modest levels (although, given your interest in German football, I'd be interested to hear of comparisons with Landesliga, Verbandsliga, etc).
But, as you hint, we're again on ground where the things that make English football attractive to the spectator aren't necessarily to its advantage in the way that it is played. I'm happy with my Tuesday night 50p half-time cuppa (often out of a proper cup), which I'll guard jealously, but I do wonder what I'm watching sometimes (as well as speculating about the true meaning/impact of all those shouts of "right shoulder!" and "left shoulder!").
|
|
bbcgull
Programmes Room Manager
Posts: 1,346
|
Post by bbcgull on Oct 23, 2008 9:32:09 GMT
I wonder how many people realsie just how far the Football pyramid goes down. The first step of non league footie is Step 1..it actually goes down to STEP 20!!! which is the Bristol Downs League Division Four. To be honest 'village recreation grounds where they are just saturday playing fields sort of start about step 7 or 8 for instance the lowest level here in my area bellow the Wessex and then Hampshire League (not including Hampshire League 2004 which is outside the pyramid) is the Portsmouth saturday League at Step 9 all of which are village Recs.
Of course it is nearly impossible for anyone to rise from Step 20 to Step 1, not only cos the investment needed would be enormous but its not as simple as just promotion. And although it could happen in miracle world. It never will.
|
|
Jon
Admin
Posts: 6,912
|
Post by Jon on Oct 23, 2008 16:17:52 GMT
You can’t really blame the current residents of Newton Abbot for the fact that the town spreads its resources over three clubs at a similar level.
You have to go back to the 1970s to apportion the blame. In 1970, Spurs was far and away the senior team – no argument at all. By 1980, little Dynamos had overtaken Spurs and Buckland had been formed ready to become a third major player.
So surely, the blame must lie with people who enjoyed “growing up” with the mighty Spurs in the 60s, but when they reached adulthood in 1970 failed to push the club forward. So we are looking at people who turned 18 in 1970 – those born in Newton Abbot in 1952.
It seems that they spent their early adulthood more interested in girls, football and beer than pursuing a keen interest in local politics. Shame on them! Why did they not cast their vote for the “Let’s Have a Professional Football Club in Newton Abbot Party”? It’s the same kind of laziness and stupidity that you currently have from people in Torbay who couldn’t be bothered to vote for the “Let’s Have Billions of Pounds of Support From Central Government Instead of Letting Them Spend it All on London, Wales and Scotland Party”.
What did these lazy, irresponsible, stupid people do when they realised that they had destroyed football in Newton Abbot? B*ggared off to London, that’s what. And have they used their vote there to elect the “Let’s Have World Peace, an End to All Poverty and a Cure For Cancer Party”? No, they voted for Boris pigging Johnson!
You would think that they would keep quiet about their shameful past, but no – you will fine them berating the current local residents telling them it’s all their fault!
Finally, I would like to add that Newton Abbot FC went pear-shaped when it was taken over by those people from Dawlish. Correct me if I am wrong, but isn’t Dawlish the wrong side of the Penn Inn roundabout?
Never trust anyone from as far north as Dawlish!
|
|
Dave
TFF member
Posts: 13,081
|
Post by Dave on Oct 23, 2008 16:23:34 GMT
Jon, that Is the funnest post I have read In ages ;Dall so true I do wonder If you aimed It at one member, look forward to any replies.
|
|
Jon
Admin
Posts: 6,912
|
Post by Jon on Oct 23, 2008 16:23:48 GMT
Great to see Bartondowns posting on here - I believe we've discussed South Devon football before on the Tony Kempster site.
It just proves that Dave need not have worried about the lurkers who never post. Here is proof that they will post when they have something to say, and when they post it will be worth waiting for.
At least I hope Bartondowns has been reading the forum, because anyone reading my last post without knowing what's gone on here before will think I'm a total lunatic.
|
|
|
Post by scottbrehaut on Oct 23, 2008 16:27:28 GMT
Jon,
LMAO!!
|
|
Dave
TFF member
Posts: 13,081
|
Post by Dave on Oct 23, 2008 16:28:29 GMT
Its OK now Jon, I have stopped worrying, Its In the past ;Dand the posts he made yesterday were more than worth waiting for and came not only as a surprise, but gave such great pleasure to read.
|
|
merse
TFF member
Posts: 2,684
|
Post by merse on Oct 23, 2008 17:27:32 GMT
Spot on, Merse, about other European models............ given your interest in German football, I'd be interested to hear of comparisons with Landesliga, Verbandsliga, etc). One thing I would hate to see our football adopt from Germany and some other European countries is the accommodation of some of the "senior" clubs being able to run second teams in the lower levels just below their Premiership. Thus you get the "reserves" of Bayern Munich playing big fallen giants like Dynamo Dresden and in recent years St Pauli have dropped from entertaining city rivals SV Hamburg to now facing SV's "reserves". Indeed, when St Pauli did enjoy their single season in the Bundesliga1, they were forced to play their "home"game with SV away so as to "maintain public order" by being able to accommodate all who wanted to be at the match. Arsene Wenger and Rafael Benitez have both said they would love this to happen in this country........................over my dead body pal - the day that happens is the day I finish my love affair with football!
|
|
merse
TFF member
Posts: 2,684
|
Post by merse on Oct 23, 2008 17:38:39 GMT
You can’t really blame the current residents of Newton Abbot for the fact that the town spreads its resources over three clubs at a similar level. So surely, the blame must lie with people who enjoyed “growing up” with the mighty Spurs in the 60s, but when they reached adulthood in 1970 failed to push the club forward. So we are looking at people who turned 18 in 1970 – those born in Newton Abbot in 1952. I won't argue with that Jon! ;D But in all seriousness, there was a very real "anti Spurs" bias in the town in the sixties just because they paid some players,and also because they had set up a "relationship" with Exeter City and later Torquay United...............how ridiculous. There were some prominent people in the town who wanted to push the club upwards, but all they met was apathy and antipathy. Forty years on, I wonder how much things have changed, if at all.
|
|
Jon
Admin
Posts: 6,912
|
Post by Jon on Oct 23, 2008 18:19:16 GMT
But in all seriousness, there was a very real "anti Spurs" bias in the town in the sixties just because they paid some players,and also because they had set up a "relationship" with Exeter City and later Torquay United...............how ridiculous. There are often mixed feelings when a team stops being a "local" team and becomes a team of "mercenaries". Back in the days when Torquay was a two club town, Babbacombe had a real reputation as a "local team for local people" whilst some looked down their noses at Torquay Town because they brought in players from Plymouth who were paid for "broken time" and expenses.
|
|
Dave
TFF member
Posts: 13,081
|
Post by Dave on Oct 24, 2008 16:31:37 GMT
I think It Is now the end Of the road for Newton Abbot football club. The first team has already been suspended by the Carlsberg South West Peninsula League for a breach of rules of association having failed to fulfill their last two Premier Division fixtures against Wadebridge Town and Clyst Rovers.
Now the South Devon League has follow suit and has suspended the Newton Abbot Reserves yesterday with immediate effect.The South Devon League made the following statement.
"In the event of Newton Abbot FC being able to demonstrate that responsible persons are put in place and authorised to act on behalf of the club, the WBW Solicitors South Devon League will reconsider its position."
Stoke Gabriel has already signed from Newton Hutcheson and other top local clubs like Dartmouth are lining up players they wish to sign.
I would hope that there will be answers given by someone to explain just how this once excellent club has got Into so much financial difficulties. But then this Is football and TUFC never gives out Information, so why should I expect any thing different from Newton.
|
|
merse
TFF member
Posts: 2,684
|
Post by merse on Oct 24, 2008 19:10:19 GMT
I would hope that there will be answers given by someone to explain just how this once excellent club has got Into so much financial difficulties. I doubt there's anyone left to make a statement.
|
|
|
Post by crispygull on Oct 27, 2008 10:07:46 GMT
Agreed, it would be a great shame for the club to go out of existence. It's always seemed to be a decent club, playing at a decent level, and with decent facilities. It got me thinking as to whether TUFC couldn't forge some sort of "partnership" with them - in order to save their football club? To my way of thinking the facilities there are possibly as good, if not better than anything we have at the Racecourse. I wonder if there is any possibility that we could bail them out and take over their existing commitments - which would include their remaining fixtures in the SW Peninsula League. I know there has been talk of forming a reserve team at TUFC and playing at that level would surely be competitive enough for our squad players? Surely we could put together a team that included some of the best local players (including those already turning out for NA) with some of our pros who are not getting a game i.e. Michael Brough or those who are returning from injury. I believe Argyle ran a reserve side at a similar level up until last year. It's just an idea - and probably not feasible, or even within the rules - but if it could "save" the club and was beneficial to TUFC then I would be all for it .... besides it's only just down the road for me, and I've always enjoyed the PSFs at Coach Road, it would be a shame to lose it. Interesting to see John Gayle (ex TUFC and current Newton Abbot manager) at the match on Saturday. He was sat next to Colin Lee in the directors box and also did the 50/50 draw at half time. I wonder if my "fantasy", for that is all it was, might just about to become some sort of reality? To me, it would make sense - but I guess there will be a few obstacles to overcome - but I reckon something might be happening.
|
|