Dave
TFF member
Posts: 13,081
|
Post by Dave on May 28, 2009 19:00:46 GMT
I’m a day behind reading my local paper and have only just read the back of Wednesdays Herald Express, that gives the impression that players are queuing up to you our club.
To be fair it is the time of the season when agents need to earn their wages, so many player will be out of contract and will be looking to get a new deal fixed up as soon as they can.
Therefore you would expect Bucks to have many agents phone him offering this player or that player. The question is are things very different now than they were when Batson owned the club.
For more years than I care to remember I only ever heard coming out of his mouth, how hard and near impossible it was to get players to join Torquay United. Many reasons have been given and discussed on forums before and one of the main reasons has always been the location of Torquay.
Any midland based player who had his family settled up there, would surely be looking for a club close by and not one that would mean having to move his family some 200 mile or more.
Yet I do think things have changed and you only need to look at the players who joined us last season. Make no mistake Exeter City fans were sick before last season even started as they saw our club sign some well known and much respected players in football terms. I know in the end City did very well on the field with the players they had, but that did not stop City fans moaning about our quality signings over theirs.
Even young Matt Green turned down what many might have felt was the better move to Oxford to sign for us instead, maybe not getting the games he would have liked last season he is questioning that decision, but he still made and felt we were the better club to sign for.
So do you think we no longer have the old problem of not attracting the players we would have targeted? Do you now think that Torquay looks like a club players who may not have considered joining TUFC before, now really think we are a club worth signing for?
If you do then what you think are the main reasons why we seem to be able to attract players more easily.
|
|
|
Post by crispygull on May 28, 2009 19:42:51 GMT
I think its fair to say that we are probably perceived as a more attractive proposition than we have been for many long years.
Unfortunately while our location can be seen as attractive to some, I would have to say that for the vast majority of pros we are seen as being a bit out on a limb and for that reason many would never consider joining us. Paul Buckle has said many times before in the past that it is always difficult getting players down here - simply because of where we are. He has often targeted players who are already in the area (Todd, Phillips, Rice, Adams, Hodges) as this avoids the need for relocation fees and I don't doubt there may be one or two more locally based players who we target this summer too.
What has changed though is the perception of how the club is seen by others and particularly by players. In this day and age, it is even more true that players from other clubs communicate with each other - so they will know the massive turnaround in our fortunes over the last two years and more (given that the club had undoubtedly become run down under Mike Bateson in his latter years at the helm) and they will know that we are now a very well run professional outfit.
What has also become an even more important factor in recent times is the stability of the club. With the news today that Bournemouth players only got paid 60% of their wages last month and are unlikely to receive any wages at all for the month of May unless the PFA bail them out (again!) and similar stories further along the South Coast at both Southampton and Weymouth earlier in the season - it has surely become more and more important an issue for a pro footballer in choosing his next club is as to how well is the club actually run?
I also think that Paul Buckle has a lot to do with how our club is portrayed in a much more professional way than it has been for many a year. I am sure he can be a very persuasive and determined negotiator - with all the attributes he had as a dogged midfielder being carried forward into his time in management. He also comes across as very ambitous and I think the club is gradually being thought of in the same way too.
Of course there will always be some that say that the only reason we are seen as being more attractive these days is purely down to the wages we pay, and in part that may be the case. I certainly think that Colin Lee, who I believe plays an important part in sorting out player budgets and contracts, has a good handle on what a players worth is, and what the going rate is.
Unfortunately it was all too often the case, particularly in the Bateson/Rosenior days that we were always looking for that "rough diamond" which simply meant someone with talent who was prepared to play for (relative) peanuts and who might just have sufficient ability to become a half decent player given the chance and the opportunity to play under a decent coach.
I don't doubt that the consortium have backed Paul Buckle to the hilt over the last couple of years and hopefully that will continue to be the case for may years to come, provided of course that the backing they provide is both sensible and prudent, which given the make up of the men responsible for the decision making at our club I am sure will always be the case.
Strange though it may seem to say it, but I also think our media exposure over the last couple of seasons, through both Setanta and the Non League Paper, together with a couple of decent cup runs and the Play Off win at Wembley, have given our profile in the game a much needed shot in the arm too. There was the feeling among many that when we dropped out of the Football League two years ago that we would simply be forgotten about as we dropped into the abyss! However, how wrong we all were, I never thought I would say it but looking back (and how great it feels to say that) I have actually thoroughly enjoyed our brief (thankfully) sojourn into the Non League ranks - well all apart from a couple of weeks at the end of last season anyway!
I certainly believe that TUFC is a pretty good place to be at the moment, for players, staff and fans alike, and hopefully we will see this borne out in the calibre of player that Bucks' brings to the club in the summer, building on what he has already achieved in the last two years.
|
|
merse
TFF member
Posts: 2,684
|
Post by merse on May 28, 2009 20:13:53 GMT
The fact is that there is a grapevine in the professional game and in years past this club had become a laughing stock for it's rotating door policy of managerial appointments, lack of training facilities and unprofessional approach to such things as player welfare, treatment of injuries, poor playing surface, and a hundred and one other small things that when added together became a big obstacle in the eyes of many prospective signings. Colin Lee was the man who dragged the then chairman kicking and screaming in an attempt to establish some proper if only modest training facilities at the Racecourse, but whilst they were in situ; Mike Bateson and Merv Benney were really an obstacle to establishing a proper professional set up that did justice to the attempt to compete in an evermore professional and demanding Football League. It's a damned hard task to establish and compete at the level of football we all want to see the club operate in but even harder when the geography of the place rules out many players signing for the club because it involves relocation.....................there are plenty of professional footballers who although they have wracked up half a dozen clubs in their careers have NEVER had to move house and have no intention of doing so in the future. Granted, there are many players who have almost reluctantly moved down there who well after their careers are over still remain in South Devon and simply love the area, but that is not the difficulty in hand for Paul Buckle or any other manager operating West of Bristol for that matter it is now and the immediate future that is all important for them and that can only be made easier by the very hard work and ambition that has been put in hand by Colin Lee and the Board in transforming the club into the one we all see and enjoy today. Many seemingly small things have been carried out............................added comfort and relaxation facilities out at the training ground, a great new playing surface, vastly improved dressing rooms and the match day experience for players families all added together have cast OUR club in a much better light than in the past and slowly but surely these things assist the manager to do his job that little bit more easily. Something else can help too.....................a more inspirational crowd and one which doesn't jump on the back of new arrivals such as the shameful way Wayne Carlisle and to a lesser extent Roscoe Dsane were singled out will benefit all of us hugely. It's something worth thinking about. Take a leaf out of the late John F Kennedy's rhetoric and ask yourself not what YOUR club can do for YOU but what YOU can do for OUR club!
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 28, 2009 20:39:15 GMT
The fact is that there is a grapevine in the professional game and in years past this club had become a laughing stock Exactly. On my mythical State of Torquay United Index - which measures things on the pitch, behind the scenes and in the mind - I can report trading is as brisk as it has been for many years. We're on the up. I'd imagine a possible move to Torquay is - under normal circumstances - a 50/50 in many players' minds for the reasons that have already been expressed so eloquently. I'd contend the current set-up is doing its best to make that a 60/40 (or better) after years of the proverbial bargepole getting in the way. Mike Bateson and Merv Benney were really an obstacle to establishing a proper professional set up that did justice to the attempt to compete in an evermore professional and demanding Football League. And it was in such a piggin' mess that Chris Roberts was a charlatan waiting to happen. a great new playing surface As paid tribute to by Frank O'Farrell at the Legends evening. Something else can help too.....................a more inspirational crowd and one which doesn't jump on the back of new arrivals such as the shameful way Wayne Carlisle and to a lesser extent Roscoe Dsane were singled out will benefit all of us hugely. It's something worth thinking about. At the risk of being labelled a "Merse groupie" - that made me smile Dave Shaw (but bloody hell, man, don't encourage the old bugger with his lurid tales that masterfully link Hayes & Yeading and Indian love nests in one fell swoop. Did anyone else notice that?) - I'll just say "'Nuff said".
|
|
Jon
Admin
Posts: 6,912
|
Post by Jon on May 28, 2009 23:50:25 GMT
whilst they were in situ; Mike Bateson and Merv Benney were really an obstacle to establishing a proper professional set up that did justice to the attempt to compete in an evermore professional and demanding Football League. That is a bit of a simplistic take on things Merse! Maybe a lack of finance was an obstacle to establishing ..... would be a fairer comment. If you look at the latest accounts you will see a further £492k of share capital pumped into the club in 2007/08 plus a note that a further loan of £370k has been made between the end of last season and the accounts being signed off in January. It would have been foolish for the two MBs to give the nod to such "professionalism" unless they were prepared to stump up the thick end of £1m - which they weren't. Like you, I am excited and delighted with what has happened to OUR club in the past two years, but it hasn't just taken a positive attitude and a load of hard work - it has taken a bucket load of cash too. It is very important that the public gets behind the new TUFC in numbers - we have been given one hell of a kickstart, but sooner or later the numbers coming through the turnstiles will be the deciding factor as to what level the club settles at. Onwards and upwards. COME ON YOU YELLOWS!
|
|
rjdgull
TFF member
Admin
Posts: 12,231
|
Post by rjdgull on May 29, 2009 12:00:06 GMT
Maybe a lack of finance was an obstacle to establishing ..... would be a fairer comment. If you look at the latest accounts you will see a further £492k of share capital pumped into the club in 2007/08 plus a note that a further loan of £370k has been made between the end of last season and the accounts being signed off in January.Unfortunately, the consortium inherited a debt with the club due to the Roberts debacle from the relegation season and I remember reading that the debt of £400000ish was converted into shares i.e paid off by some of or all of the consortium and their individual stakes in the club re-proportioned accordingly. The actual first season in charge of the club resulted in a small profit ( Thanks to the cup runs in the FA cup and trophy including some TV money along the way) and did not need any investment to achieve this. Unfortunately the dreadful drop off in attendances this season obviously resulted in the club again losing money, hence the loan. (which Alex Rowe was quoted as saying the consortium was comfortable with) However, the FA Cup run and play offs will hopefully have mitigated this loss somewhat. I suppose the conclusion from the above is that you have got to speculate to accumulate and there is no reason as to why the books can't be balanced over the medium term but someone (the consortium) needs to stand any losses that inevitably will occur from time to time to avoid the red zone. The club is in a relatively strong position with no debt to service in these difficult times and if supporters, local business and sponsors pull their weight then there is no reason as to why we, as the club, can't punch above our weight.
|
|
Dave
TFF member
Posts: 13,081
|
Post by Dave on May 29, 2009 16:51:14 GMT
I do get disapointred when Merv Benny gets blame laid on him, he has never been a major shareholder and did so much around the club for free, as he loved the club as much as anyone.He is also a decent man and one who in my view has not been treated the way he deserved by some at the club now, but I fully understand why that is.
I'm not really interested into going into that statement, but we all know why Bateson and how Bateson ran the club and the reasons for doing so and why in the end he really had enough and maybe even wished he had not even bothered saving TUFC in the first place.
When he bought the club every single fan were saying that Bateson and his money had saved TUFC, I'm sure Jon could explain the full circumstances back at that time. Even before he did buy it he was putting money into the club through sponsorship and also local football.
He did in my view get to a point where he felt the people of Torbay were not really bothered about the football club, he simply was not prepared to put anymore of his own money into the club.
Therefore the club had to live within its own means and only pay out what it could afford, it meant cutbacks and the end of our youth scheme and let us not forget all the real nastiness aimed at him and his family from so called fans of the club.
I don't blame him for wanting out and I would have understood if he did the deal with Roberts to punish those who siagged his family off in the way they did. It has always been the big question in my mind, did he get conned by Roberts like so many others? did he know Roberts would fail and make fans wish he had not left? did he expect to come back at the death and save the club again?
The real difference now is our board are all fans and have been prepared to put their money in and the main reason surely has been to get TUFC back into the league. But Jon is right and the fans and people of Torbay now need to show by giving their full support to the club, that their money has been worth spending.
There could come a time when they do look at the cost to their own pockets and ask questions, Barton gave his view on how things might progress with the consortium.
I did agree with his thoughts and have already had the same thoughts some time ago. It was that over the coarse of time one of the consortium might want to move on and then a new member would be found.
They all can't go on for ever anyway and as long as most maintain their interest and are prepared to put money in when needed then we will remain in good sound hands. In many years time it may be the case that only a few will still be remaining, but would have all been replaced by like minded people who share the same love and dreams for the club.
|
|
davethegull
TFF member
Posts: 1,094
Favourite Player: Dave Caldwell
|
Post by davethegull on May 29, 2009 17:09:29 GMT
I fully agree with the above posts. I never really subscribed to MB's whine that it was difficult to attract players down here due to location. It was due to us being seen as a bit of a joke, paying peanuts and getting monkeys. That's a bit harsh on some of the gems we did have here but generalising.
The Board and Colin Lee have changed all that. PB has had the tools to do the job and been professional in his approach and very hardworking. Probably the first time a manager has had this luxury. "Selling" TUFC must be quite a bit easier now than in the past. Given our stabililty in both a financial sense and behind the scenes should be a big plus in the equation for a player deciding whether to move down here. No wonder agents are on the phone, we are one of the few clubs at this level who can assure the player he'll get paid.
Without raising my expectations too high, i think we could be surprised with the calibre of signing we can make. So, it's down to PB to get it done.
|
|
Jon
Admin
Posts: 6,912
|
Post by Jon on May 29, 2009 19:14:40 GMT
Unfortunately, the consortium inherited a debt with the club due to the Roberts debacle from the relegation season and I remember reading that the debt of £400000ish was converted into shares i.e paid off by some of or all of the consortium and their individual stakes in the club re-proportioned accordingly. The actual first season in charge of the club resulted in a small profit ( Thanks to the cup runs in the FA cup and trophy including some TV money along the way) and did not need any investment to achieve this. Unfortunately the dreadful drop off in attendances this season obviously resulted in the club again losing money, hence the loan. (which Alex Rowe was quoted as saying the consortium was comfortable with) However, the FA Cup run and play offs will hopefully have mitigated this loss somewhat. I suppose the conclusion from the above is that you have got to speculate to accumulate and there is no reason as to why the books can't be balanced over the medium term but someone (the consortium) needs to stand any losses that inevitably will occur from time to time to avoid the red zone. The club is in a relatively strong position with no debt to service in these difficult times and if supporters, local business and sponsors pull their weight then there is no reason as to why we, as the club, can't punch above our weight. Some good points there rjd. You are right that there was a small profit of c£10k on the 2007/08 season. Against that, there was c£200k invested in "tangible assets" - presumably mainly the massive refurbs to hospitality areas. These will pay their way in the medium term, but are a cash drain up front. All that, as you say, was planned and expected. There was £200k in the bank at the end of 2007/08, so for us to need another £370k loan shows how we were leaking money when our gates were so disappointing. I think this season's figures will look very bad with gates down over 28% - the biggest fall of all 116 clubs at national level - and playing budget significantly increased. Play-offs and FA Cup will mean things will not be as bad as they could have been - but remember we had similar revenues last season. Like you, I am confident that the situation is well-managed and under control, but it is worth remembering how much financial backing you need to try to do what is going on at Plainmoor. That explains why this has not happened before. If the Board had not been ready and able to provide the financial backing, they would have been foolhardy to embark on such an ambitious course and it would all have ended in tears. We could not have been more fortunate in the people who have taken this club on, and winning promotion was absolutely vital in allowing them to continue to crack on moving the club forwards. I really believe the momentum would have been severely slowed, possibly even halted, if we had not gone up. We will never have a better opportunity to make this club the best it can possibly be - I really hope that everyone rallies to the cause. COME ON YOU YELLOWS!
|
|
rjdgull
TFF member
Admin
Posts: 12,231
|
Post by rjdgull on May 29, 2009 21:27:29 GMT
Jon - obviously a man with his hand firmly on the balance sheet. Agree with your above remarks 100%.
Didn't know about the £200,000 in cash floating around (flash or what!) but would only take about 15 games with a thousand less supporters attending to eat that up by early October. (Are you sure that wasn't ear marked for the co-incidental similar amount needed for the refurbishment works?) In respect of the loan, that may or may not have been totally required as cash flow improved during the second half of the season.
However, what it does prove is how essential the off the pitch activities are in influencing the on the pitch game
|
|
merse
TFF member
Posts: 2,684
|
Post by merse on May 30, 2009 6:31:38 GMT
That the club effectively ran at a loss of around £10,000 a WEEK last season is food for thought for every intelligent Gulls fan and underlines the very urgent need for the public of Torbay to get off their fat arses and actually support this football club of ours in the manner that is necessary to retain Football League status for any meaningful length of time in the future. The very fact that Football League status has been retrieved after just two seasons in the BSP is admirable indeed. Remember it took Martin O'Neill the very same time scale to achieve what Paul Buckle has done and that was at a much more vibrant and already structurally sound Wycombe Wanderers, and look how THEIR public responded! On the other hand, struggling Accrington Stanley stand on the edge of administration this morning after seeing their gates sink to levels well below those that witnessed their elevation such a short time ago. It will be critical indeed just how the lethargic and apathetic population of Torbay and the surrounding South Devon folk who significantly augment the support at present react.....................but I'm not holding my breath in anticipation of any spectacular increase and don't forget that whilst the money up front from the commendable season ticket sales drive is "in the bank" so to speak, there will be much reduced cash flow during the season as a consequence ~ unless those gates improve dramatically!
|
|
davethegull
TFF member
Posts: 1,094
Favourite Player: Dave Caldwell
|
Post by davethegull on May 30, 2009 6:48:23 GMT
How to achieve that tho merse is the question. You can't force people to come. The vibe at the club is a positive and professional one. The board have to come up with imaginative marketing strategies to encourage attendance ( i don't have the answers unfortunately). However this has to start with the "product". The teams success is vital to putting bums on seats. So, can we afford a period of consolidation or should we be going straight for the promised land of promotion? Hmmm, difficult one to answer.
Maybe a campaign aimed at the Prem club supporters of the bay. Encourage them to come and see "live" football and all that entails. Have the Gulls as their 2nd team to support.
What about investigating a change in kick off times? We used to ko at 7.30 on a saturday night. The football playing people of the bay could then make it. Sunday KO's? Friday night? Other teams have tried this.
It's a difficult task but one i think has to be attempted.
|
|
Dave
TFF member
Posts: 13,081
|
Post by Dave on May 30, 2009 9:30:38 GMT
Merse I can assure you that the bums of people in the westcounty are no fatter than bums you will find anywhere else in the UK, I will refrain from making any comments on the following few words you could not resist to put in your post
lethargic and apathetic population of Torbay
I always wonder who the 12000 were who went to Wenbley to support the team in the play-off final. You can be sure most of the 2000 die hards who were at plainmoor to witness our last season as a BSP team, would have been there.
Also many of the exiles who play a big part in giving the team such great support at away games would have also have been there, not sure what figure could be put on the exiles but I would guess it could be around the 1500 mark.
So who were the rest? well some would have been the missing 1000 who did not fancy watching a second season of BSP football and one would hope that now we are back in the football league, we will see many of those now at plainmoor supporting the team at our home games.
Some for sure would have been fans who stopped going a long time ago, maybe due to Bateson? who knows what their reasons were, but they will always be the hardest ones to win back as regular paying fans.
There would be some who are not fans as such but went to support the local team, believe it or not there are people here in the Bay who are not football supports as such, will give support to the towns team on such a big day.
I would think that we will see just over 3000 home fans be at the first home games this season, as is always the case good entertaining football and those at the game seeing a team of players giving their all to win the game, will see those fans coming again to the next match.
A good start may also play a big part in getting more up to Plainmoor, but make no mistake, a bad start and rubbish hoof ball football on offer, will see numbers drop back toward the 2000 mark.
There will aways be the die hards, while others (the floaters) will come if they get entertained and feel that spending their leisure money to watch TUFC was money well spent.
Over the years and more so in the Webb and Bateson times, the club has lost many good regular fans who now do other things with their time at the weekends.
Winning fans back and getting the numbers up to a level that not only the board fully deserve, but ones that will give us the funds to become successful as a league club, will not happen over night.
There is I believe enough people who have in the past supported the club, or still have TUFC somewhere in their heart, to fill plainmoor, but its how you get them all back that will always be the one million dollar question.
|
|
|
Post by aussie on May 30, 2009 12:31:23 GMT
Mr.Hankey was a floater! ;D
|
|